Western and Islamic Constitutionalism
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.6092/issn.2724-6299/22081Keywords:
western constitutionalism, constitutional democracy, legislative democracy, islamic constitutionalism, secularismAbstract
This essay aims to develop the comparison between Western constitutionalism and Islamic constitutionalism. In the Western tradition the term constitutionalism points to the limitation of government through law. There have been different models of constitutionalism, in particular the American and the French ones, that can be understood in the light of the two interpretive categories of constitutional democracy and legislative democracy, respectively. The developments of contemporary constitutionalism appear very complex, as today's constitutions are the reflection of the cultural, religious, social and political pluralism of current societies. Therefore, the centrality of interpretation is imposed, whose complexity derives from the fact that pluralistic constitutions merge legal issues and moral issues together. About Islamic constitutionalism some Islamic thinkers consider secularism a philosophy, while Islam is another form of philosophy, which has its own vision of human life, rights and duties. In this perspective it follows that it is reasonable to think that constitutionalism can be achieved differently in different societies depending on the conceptions of rights and duties that are accepted and shared.
Downloads
References
Alexy R. (1986). Theorie der Grundrechte (Suhrkamp). Translated into English by Julian Rivers. as A Theory of Constitutional Rights (2002) (Oxford University Press).
Amor A. (1994). Constitution et religion dans les États musulmans, in Constitution et religion, Proceedings of the 10th session of the Académie Internationale de Droit Constitutionnel, Tunis, 1994 (Presses de l’Université des Sciences Sociales de Toulouse).
An-Naʿīm A. Ahmed (1996). Toward an Islamic Reformation: Civil Liberties, Human Rights, and International Law (Syracuse University Press).
An-Naʿīm A. A. (1989). Constitutionalism and Islamization in the Sudan, in Africa Today 36, no. 3/4.
El-Awa M. S. (1980). On the Political System of the Islamic State (American Trust Publications).
Bahlul R. (2007). Is Constitutionalism Compatible with Islam? chap. 15, in P. Costa, and D. Zolo (eds.), The Rule of Law: History, Theory and Criticism (Springer).
Bähr O. von (1864). Der Rechtsstaat (Wigand).
Belvisi F. (2000). Società multiculturale, diritti, costituzione (CLUEB).
Ben Achour Y. (1992). Politique, religion et droit dans le monde arabe (Cérès).
Benhabib S. (2004). The Rights of Others: Aliens, Residents and Citizens (Cambridge University Press).
Böckenförde E.-W. (1976). Entstehung und Wandel des Rechtsstaatsbegriffs, in Staat, Gesellschaft, Freiheit (Suhrkamp).
Bolingbroke H. Saint John, 1st Viscount. Letter X (1735). Dissertation upon Parties, to the Right Honorable Sir Robert Walpole, in vol. 2 of The Works of the Late Right Honorable Henry St. John, Lord Viscount Bolingbroke (London: 1754).
Bongiovanni G. (1998). R. Alexy e il costituzionalismo, in F. Belvisi (ed.), La filosofia del diritto costituzionale e i problemi del liberalismo contemporaneo (CLUEB).
Bongiovanni G. and Gozzi G. (1997). Democrazia, in A.Barbera, and G. Zanetti (eds.), Le basi filosofiche del costituzionalismo: Lineamenti di filosofia del diritto costituzionale (Laterza).
Brown N. J. (2002). Constitutions in a Nonconstitutional World: Arab Basic Laws and the Prospects for Accountable Government (State University of New York Press).
Burke E. (2003). Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790) (Yale University Press).
Campanini M. (2008). Ideologia e politica nell’Islam (Il Mulino).
Cerrina Feroni G. (2017). Diritto costituzionale e società multiculturale, in Rivista AIC, no 1.
Dogliani M. (1994). Introduzione al diritto costituzionale (Il Mulino).
Dworkin R. (1977). Taking Rights Seriously (Duckworth).
Fioravanti M. (1991). Appunti di storia delle costituzioni moderne (Giappichelli).
Frankenberg G. (2000). Tocqueville’s Question: The Role of a Constitution in the Process of Integration, in Ratio Juris 13, no. 1.
Ghannouchi R. (1993). Al-Ḥurriyāt al ‘Āmmah fī al Dawla al Islāmiyya (Public liberties in the Islamic state).
Grimm D. (1996). Il futuro della costituzione, in G. Zagrebelsky, P. P. Portinaro, and J. Luther (eds.), Il futuro della costituzione (Einaudi).
Grimm D. (1980). Reformalisierung des Rechtsstaats als Demokratiepostulat?, in Juristische Schulung, 10.
Groppi T. (2018). Multiculturalismo 4.0, in AIC - Osservatorio costituzionale, Fasc. 1.
Habermas J. (1996). Between Facts and Norms: Contributions to a Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy, trans. W. Rehg (The MIT Press). Originally, Faktizität und Geltung: Beiträge zur Diskurstheorie des Rechts und des demokratischen Rechtsstaats (1992) (Suhrkamp).
Hamilton A. (2022). A View of the Constitution of the Judicial Department in Relation to the Tenure of Good Behavior (May 28, 1788). Federalist 78, in Hamilton A., Madison J., and Jay J. The Federalist Papers (Open Road Integrated Media).
Kelsen H. (1955). Foundations of Democracy, in Ethics: An International Journal of Social, Political, and Legal Philosophy, 66, no. 1.
Laoust Henri (ed.). (1986). Le Califat dans la Doctrine de Rashīd Riḍā (Maisonneuve). Traduction annotée d’al- Khilāfa. Cairo, 1341 (1922-3).
Leibholz G. (1957). Demokratie und Rechtsstaat, in Schriftenreihe der Landeszentrale für Heimatdienst in Niedersachsen, Heft 5.
McIlwain C. H. (1958). Constitutionalism: Ancient and Modern (1940) (Great Seal Books).
Paine T. (1953 a). Rights of Man, part I, in Common Sense (1776) and Other Political Writings (The Liberal Arts Press).
Paine T. (1953 b). “Common Sense” (1776), in Common Sense (1776) and Other Political Writings (The Liberal Arts Press).
Raz J. (1994). Multiculturalism: A Liberal Perspective”, in Dissent 41.
Romano S. (1969). Lo Stato moderno e la sua crisi (1909) (Giuffrè).
Rousseau J.-J. (1994). The Social Contract (1762), trans. Christopher Betts (Oxford University Press), bk. II, chap vi.
al-Sanhūrī, 'Abd al Razzāq A. (1926). Le Califat. Son Evolution vers une Société des Nations Orientale (Geuthner).
Schumpeter J. (1950). Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy (1942), 3. ed. (Allen & Unwin).
Shawi T. (1992). Fiqh al-shura wa-l-istishara (The jurisprudence of Consultation and Seeking Advice) (Dar al-wafa’).
Tully J. (1997). Strange Multiplicity: Constitutionalism in an Age of Diversity (Cambridge University Press).
Walzer M. (1991). Constitutional Rights and the Shape of Civil Society, chap. 6, in R. E. Calvert (ed.), The Constitution of the People: Reflections on Citizens and Civil Society (University Press of Kansas).
Zagrebelsky G. (2007). La virtù del dubbio: Intervista su etica e diritto (Laterza).
Zagrebelsky G. (1996). Storia e costituzione, in G. Zagrebelsky, P. P. Portinaro and J. Luther (eds.), Il futuro della costituzione (Einaudi).
Zagrebelsky G. (1992). Il diritto mite (Einaudi).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Gustavo Gozzi
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
